(My Middle East)

77 days with a journalist, Lebanon, and a list of non sequiturs

Archive for July 24th, 2009

Summer reading Vol. 4 | Engaging the Muslim World

leave a comment »

The fourth edition of the summer reading series is Engaging the Muslim World by Juan Cole. I hadn’t read a whole lot of Cole’s work before this, maybe just his recent Iran stuff, so this a nice change of authors from Friedman last week.

When I read academic books I usually keep a small page of paper with me to jot things down that I want to remember. For this book, I kept a lot of notes. Which isn’t to say that the book was particularly good or bad, but that Cole went after dozens of topics, anything from Energy Independence to Wahhabis, and Syrian Baathists.

The book  didn’t quite read like one continuous work rather a series of essays on different topics. It was a little bit disconcerting because even inside each chapter Cole would use ‘breaks’ to jump around to different decades and subtopics inside that chapter.

Because the books includes so many topics, its clearly wasn’t academically exhaustive. Cole sometimes glosses over details to help make his point. A particular reach was his insistence that VP Dick Cheney wanted war with Iraq to secure accesses to Iraqi Oil by American companies. But the books is instructive in pointing out the hypocrisies and incongruity in American foreign policy. Cole points to the lack of logic behind American claims that most Saudi Arabian Wahhabis are radical or the irony when the Ford administration authorized a plutonium reprocessing plant in Iran in the 70’s (Cole is insistent that Iran is not attempting to get a nuclear weapon, a claim that David Sanger in The Inheritance, my next book, strongly disagrees with)

In the end Engaging the Muslim World is a series of reminders about the very western, Americanized way that most people in the U.S. view the world. If you’ve spent your life watching American TV and reading the New York Times, its a great reminder that there are other perspectives out there and American policy isn’t nearly as clear cut as its made out to be.

That being said, Cole uses the end of every chapter to make sweeping recommendations about policy changes and leaves little room for nuance on complex issues, he always seems to have an excuse for what America is doing wrong that makes one ideology not match up with another. But the book is a great jumping off point for a start of a much more through analysis into all the topics Cole covers.

Heres some of the key points that Cole brings up (his ideas not mine):

  • U.S. has acted to protect its energy interest in the world, installing and backing up oil regimes (Syria, Lebanon, Iraq). Neomercantalism is dying/dead
  • Oil dependency doesnt work, most alternative fuels wont work either
  • Solar is the way forward
  • U.S. needs better relationship with “Islamic oil”.
  • U.S. backed the militant Islamic fighters in the 90’s who are not fought as terrorists
  • Muslim world and Western world are equally religious. Secular politics in America is disconected from grass roots America
  • Saudi 9/11 connection not plausible. Bin Laden hated Saudi royal family
  • King Saud was the counter weight to Nasser
  • Wahabis not killing people (very sympathetic to Saudi Arabia)
  • Abdullah acts in ways better for Saudi and America than Fahd did
  • U.S. surge in Iraq achieved dubious results partially by more ethnic cleansing
  • Hypocrcy of not granting Iraqis Assaylum in any reasonable numbers even those who helped Americans
  • U.S. ignores leftist insurgents because it doesnt fit the message
  • Federally Administered Tribal Area in Pakistan outside of the law, no local administrator. Pashtuns have system of equality
  • Pakistan military/intelligence funds the Taliban
  • Iraq invasion increased Iran power
  • Ahmedinijad not global threat. Khameini holds the cards
  • Iran won’t attack Israel
  • US nuke approval in Iran in 76
  • Great Game (pre-WWI) to partition Iran between British and Russians made Iran deeply suspicious
  • Democratically elected Mossadegh deposed in CIA coup bad for relations
  • Hezbollah = Small paramilitary
  • In the conclusion: Stop being bigots, no more Islamiphobia or American/Islam anxiety, West needs to translate enlightenment ideas and books that aren’t available in the Middle East, engagement is the key, international frustration over Palestinian issue is building, energy demand will become a crisis

Final Rating (out of 5): 3.5

Summer Reading Ratings

Killing Mr Lebanon by Nicholas Blanford: 4.5

In the Path of Hizbullah by Ahmad Nizar Hamzeh: 3.7

From Beirut to Jerusalem by Thomas Friedman: 4.0

Engaging the Muslim World by Juan Cole: 3.5

The Inheritance by David E. Sanger

The Great War for Civilization by Robert Fisk

Advertisements

Written by stephenddockery

July 24, 2009 at 11:15 am